For over 40 years, Old Chicago locations in 22 states have been serving up distinctive craft beers and high-quality food, in a relaxed, casual atmosphere. Although there’s no official Old Chicago secret menu, this innovative chain has a full menu that’s not limited to their Chicago-style pizza, which is some of the best you’ll find outside the city itself. There’s also plenty of tasty appetizers, pasta and even delicious desserts to satisfy just about every craving.

While the Old Chicago secret menu doesn’t really exist, there are many ways to make your order special. Give your favorite dishes some extra flavor by switching up the sauces and toppings whenever you’re in the mood for some unique tastes.

Official secret menu vs. customer creations?

With so many options on the menu, there’s something for everyone at Old Chicago. That shouldn’t stop you from experimenting a bit, though. From unique twists on appetizers to delicious mixed drinks, you can enjoy some new flavors every time you stop by. Give these customer creations a try:

• While the Provolone Sticks with marinara sauce are a customer favorite, you can make this classic appetizer even better by switching out the sauce for something a little different. In the mood for spice? Substitute marinara for Buffalo Sauce. Can’t get enough cheese? Ask for the Bleu Cheese Dressing as your dipping sauce instead.
• Old Chicago is known for their extensive beer selection, but the bartenders also make great mixed drinks. Turn your Strawberry or Pomegranate Lemonade into an adult beverage – just ask for a shot of your favorite spirit, sip and enjoy!

The most popular Old Chicago secret menu items

While there’s no official Old Chicago secret menu, keep in mind that there are plenty of delicious options on the regular menu. Whether you’re in the mood for something spicy, savory, sweet, or you’d like to have it all, check out these delicious options on your next visit:

• Classic Bone-In Wings with Buffalo Dry Rub (appetizer)
• Buffalo Chicken Rolls (appetizer)
• Italian Garlic Roasted Cauliflower (appetizer)
• Tuscan Chicken with Spinach Specialty Pizza (entrée)
• Chicago 7 Calzone (entrée)
• Samuel Adams Battered Fish & Chips (entrée)
• Stacked Turkey & Bacon Club Sandwich (entrée)
• Cheesecake with Fresh Berries (dessert)
• Dark Chocolate Fudge Cake (dessert)

Each of these items on the menu can be customized so that you get the exact flavors you’re craving – just let your friendly server know about the modifications you want. Some items even encourage customizations, like the Craft Your Own Mac N’ Cheese or the Craft Your Own Calzone. With plenty of toppings, cheeses and sauces on hand, eating at Old Chicago becomes a customizable culinary adventure. If you’re in doubt, ask your server for suggestions—she may have some favorite dishes of her own that you can’t miss!

How to order from the hidden menu

While you’re out of luck if you’re looking for an Old Chicago secret menu, that shouldn’t discourage you from customizing your meal the next time you stop by. Whether you’re in the mood for a spicy starter, a pizza covered in tasty toppings or a decadent dessert, this casual spot has you covered. Feel free to substitute sauces, toppings and more whenever you’re in the mood for some of the best flavors to come from the Windy City!