If you think a sandwich is just a sandwich, you haven’t been to Jersey Mike’s. This fast-food chain with over 1,700 locations has so many meats, toppings, cheeses and more to turn the humble sandwich into something extraordinary. And, if you want to get creative with your order, there’s even a Jersey Mike’s secret menu to explore.

Whether you’re new to this sub chain, or a loyal fan, there are enough hot and cold sandwich options to satisfy your cravings. If you’ve tried everything on the regular menu, try any of the many tasty options on Jersey Mike’s secret menu.

Official secret menu vs. customer creations?

Creative customers have been modifying the Jersey Mike’s menu for years and have come up with some great menu hacks. They also take advantage of the flat-top grill, which gives the already-delicious ingredients some extra flavor. Here are some suggestions to help you put your own spin on the menu:

• Craving something spicy? The #13 Original Italian has some zing all by itself due to the flavors of the meats, but you can amp it up even further! Just add Chipotle Mayo and Frank’s Red Hot Sauce and get ready to set your tastebuds on fire.
• Turn the traditional #8 Sub Club into something truly special by modifying your order in some creative ways. Ask your sandwich artist for grilled mayo – they’ll put it on the bun and throw it on the grill face-down for some extra crunch texture. If you’re into onions, ask them to throw those on the grill, too. You’ll get caramelized onions that add a nice sweetness to any sandwich.

The most popular Jersey Mike’s secret menu items

Jersey Mike’s secret menu provides many delicious options to satisfy your sandwich craving. You may even be able to create an entirely new sandwich of your own with all the meats, cheeses and toppings you can choose from. Just tell your sandwich-maker the modifications you want, or ask them for some insider information on their favorite menu hacks. Give these great off-menu favorites a try the next time you stop by:

• For the ham lovers out there, the secret menu creation called the #5 Super Sub is sure to please. This sandwich is loaded with the three ham varieties you’ll find at every Jersey Mike’s location: boiled ham, procuittini and cappacuolo. It’s similar to the #13 Original Italian, but it’s made without the salami and pepperoni.
• Not all locations carry barbecue sauce, but if you’re lucky and you stop by a restaurant that does, order the #19 BBQ Beef Your sandwich artist will grill up roast beef with barbecue sauce to make a tasty sub that might just become your new favorite.
• You could order the off-menu delicacy #79 Grilled Italian. It comes with cheese, ham, salami and pepperoni grilled until everything is crips and melted. If you’re feeling especially hungry, order the #13 thrown on the grill – it’s basically the same sandwich, but with cappacuolo and proscuittini added.

How to order from the Jersey Mike’s secret menu

If you want to order from Jersey Mike’s secret menu, all you have to do is ask! Your sandwich artist likely knows the secret menu items and recipes by name. If they don’t, there’s probably another staff member on hand who does. The friendly employees at Jersey Mike’s are ready for anything, including all your special requests. No matter what you’re craving, a sub with some spice or a sandwich busting with all the meats on hand, feel free to modify the menu at Jersey Mike’s and satisfy your appetite for flavor!